The Rev. Joseph Farnes
All Saints, Boise
Proper 7A
It’s been a long-running joke of who’s in charge of the church. Bishops think they are, priests think they are, vestries think they are, but truly, it’s the altar guild. It’s the people who get stuff done and without whom the church comes to a grinding halt. (If you want to know the real power behind the scenes, it’s Linda Stark.) But in other places of the Anglican Communion, the people who are the real movers, shakers, and leaders of the church are the people of the Mothers’ Union. They are the ones who get stuff done, who know what’s really going on. (Yes, it is a smidge funny that I’m talking about the Mothers’ Union on Fathers’ Day, but I know you’ll roll with it)
The Mothers’ Union was started in Victorian England and spread through the British Empire. The concept was that the mothers (and grandmothers, and aunties) of parishes should support one another and care for families. The rigid stratification of Victorian England’s social hierarchy meant that the servants and the workers were at the bottom, separated from the wealthy and the aristocracy except insofar as the wealthy could offer pity-filled charity. The concept of the Mothers’ Union was to bring the women of the parish together to support one another, to care for children, and, eventually, to advocate for the needs of children and families, too.
It feels like a natural fit. Those who care for children should care for the children of others, too. Children deserve the resources and support they need to grow up healthy! If we say that children are our future, then every child is part of our universal future.
And, yet, this is also not a universal perspective.
We see this in our Bible reading from Genesis today. Sarah is worried that her son Isaac will be competing for an inheritance with his half-brother Ishmael. Sarah wants to make sure that her son has the best; the fate or even the survival of (to use Sarah’s phrase) the “son of the slave woman” is of little concern to Sarah. Cast out Hagar, cast out Ishmael. The free mother against the enslaved mother. That child is perceived as a threat to the well-being of my child, and so I will use all my power to eliminate the threat. Instead of viewing all children as sacred gifts of God with a whole future ahead, some children are seen as enemies in miniature.
Which children matter, and which children don’t matter?
In the missile strikes on Iran this spring, girls were killed when their school was bombed. Do those children still matter, or have we moved on to another talking point? The Israeli national security minister said this weekend that for every Israeli mother’s tears, that a thousand Lebanese mothers should be weeping – and given that children get treated as “future combatants” I don’t think this rhetoric is hollow hyperbole.
But we see this same logic play at home.
How do we as a culture treat children in poor families? Do we give them safe places to play and grow, nutritious food? Or do we means-test them to make sure that no dollar goes to help them that could be directed toward yet another corporate subsidy? What about the abominable concept of school lunch debt? Or how public schools for children are perpetually underfunded and expected to make more and more miracles happen, when charter schools can choose which kids to accept and which kids to reject, and private schools can get vouchers paid by public funds?
What about how Black children and Latino children have to learn at an early age that white people will perceive them differently – that the young white teen can be seen as being a mischievous kid, but the Black teen will be seen as a threat? Remember Black teen Trayvon Martin in 2012 was heading home from a convenience store buying snacks and was killed by a vigilante who’d decided the teenager was a threat, and white teen Kyle Rittenhouse could take an assault rifle to a protest in another state and shoot people and be acquitted. How we failed Trayvon in allowing a culture that sees Black kids any differently from their peers, and how we failed Kyle in letting him grow up equating strength with power, violence, and privilege.
Or what about LGBT children – who often grow up with messages that they are not loved as they are, or that their safety is predicated on being in the closet? Children are incredibly attune to their environment; they learn the emotional landscape around them and know what is expected and how to stay safe. When I was in kindergarten, I was always jealous of the kindergarten classroom next door because they had a dollhouse that I would have loved to play with – but I also knew even as a kindergartner I wasn’t “supposed” to want to play house, just like how I knew that it wasn’t ok for a red-blooded eastern Idaho boy to have purple as his favorite color – red, green, and blue were the acceptable choices. I had learned these expectations years before I even really understood what “gay” meant. I knew how to hide in the closet long before threats had ever been spoken aloud. My story is hardly unique.
And so we live in a world that wants to idolize childhood for a few, and refuses to see the belovedness of countless children because they are “others” – strangers at best, enemies at worst. Just as every adult is our neighbor, so every child is our child – worthy of care, worthy of respect, worthy of support and nurture. But that means confronting how our structures and systems and cultures are set up against children. It means that we are confronted with uncomfortable truths – we read in the Bible that Jesus says we have to receive the Kingdom of God as children, that we should care for children, and yet it’s much easier to dismiss children by going through the abstract lens of “policy choices.” It’s not that we’re not feeding children, educating children, protecting children from war, violence and poverty – that’s just the impact of neutral policy choices. It’s nothing personal. It’s just policy.
But Jesus will not be impressed by us shifting blame to politicians and policy decisions.
Jesus challenges us to move past the closed-off image of family – that all I care about is my flesh-and-blood, and who cares about the rest. Jesus wants us to have much bigger hearts than that. If you love your child as a beloved child of God, and if you can see every other child as a beloved child of God, if you can see every child, every little child, every teenager, every adult, every elder as a child of God, as an image of Jesus, then you get the Gospel. They are real children of God, nearby or far away.
Jesus asks us to move past the closed-off family that Sarah wants, that sees Ishmael as a threat. Jesus asks us to see the worth and dignity of every child. Imagine if Sarah had watched Ishmael playing with Isaac and, instead of wanting to get rid of a perceived threat to her child, imagine if Sarah had smiled and seen two children of God playing as children are called to do. Imagine if Sarah, the free woman, had seen herself as an “aunt” to Ishmael, or a co-mother to the enslaved woman, Hagar. Imagine if Sarah had seen herself as a mother in union with other mothers for a better future for all children. Imagine what that would have done for the world. That’s the kind of heart that changes the world for the better. That’s the kind of heart that should be in charge of everything. That is the heart of the parent – who sees all children as worthy of life and love. Amen.